Restaurant Review: Black Rock Kitchen and Bar

Review: Black Rock Kitchen and Bar

Location: 491 Amherst Street, Buffalo
Cuisine: New American
Web site:

Black Rock Kitchen and Bar is a bright new addition to Buffalo’s restaurant scene – a place that almost makes you feel like you’ve been transported to a fancy city like Boston or New York. But no, Black Rock Kitchen and Bar is right here in Buffalo.

I went for dinner on a recent Saturday night with two friends. When we walked in and asked for a table, the hostess said they were booked up for the entire night, but that we could order from the full menu at the bar. I don’t always enjoy eating while sitting at a bar, and when I do, I often find myself wistfully looking over at the tables and wishing I had a real seat. But the bar at BRK&B had comfortable stools (with backs!) and more than enough space to eat.

And eat we did! The menu was full of tempting options, but not an overwhelming amount. There was also a large list of specials. I appreciated how there were a variety of dishes at different price points. It’s a great place to take a varied group of eaters, since there are simple options for the less adventurous (like the Steak Sandwich) all the way up to dishes that would make foodies go nuts (like the Foie Gras French Toast).

We all had a hard time deciding what to order, but we each ordered an entrée and split an appetizer. Our appetizer was a local mushroom and goat cheese pizzetta, which was large enough for one person to eat as a main dish. Mushrooms and goat cheese are one of my favorite combinations, so I was all about this dish. The pizzetta was sprinkled with truffle oil, which provided a decadent extra touch. Needless to say, the three of us fought over the last piece!

I chose the Hawaiian Sea Bass for my entrée, which was a special for that night. It was one of the most delicious pieces of fish I’ve ever eaten. Perfectly cooked and seasoned, the fish was served on a bed of potato and leek hash, which I gobbled right up. In retrospect, I would have preferred a higher ratio of potatoes to leeks in the hash, but that’s a minor quibble. It was a great dish and the smaller portion size was a welcome change from the many local restaurants that seem to think quantity equals quality.

My friends ordered the Fish Tacos from the regular menu and Lobster Tail from the specials. Of course, I had to try a few bites of each dish. The Fish Tacos were decent, although I probably would have been disappointed if I had ordered them as my own entrée. I love how Mexican food is so bright and colorful, but these tacos were only various shades of beige, which made them look slightly unappetizing.

The Lobster Tail was definitely a little bit of a splurge, but looked completely worth it. It was served on a bed of some sort of risotto, which I don’t think I tried because I was too busy enjoying my own entrée.

We all agreed that we’d be back again, not only because of the delicious food, but also to enjoy the restaurant’s warm atmosphere. The décor is very well done, with the walls painted a warm purple. My favorite aspect of the décor was the bronze tin ceiling. It might be a faux tin ceiling, but whatever, it looked good and helped add to the restaurant’s warm, homey feel.

In all, Black Rock Kitchen and Bar is a welcome addition to Buffalo’s restaurant scene and I recommend it to anyone who is looking for a good meal. I hope it succeeds (being totally booked on a Saturday night is a good sign!) and inspires additional development on Amherst Street.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s